Article

What cyber insurers now expect from your IT controls

Insurers increasingly want evidence of the basics before offering or renewing cover: MFA, endpoint detection, tested backups, patching and an incident response plan. Your questionnaire answers can matter at claim time.

The short answer

Every insurer and policy differs, but applications and renewal questionnaires commonly ask about:

  • MFA on email, remote access, admins
  • EDR, and who monitors it
  • Separated, tested backups
  • Scheduled patching, no exposed unsupported systems
  • Awareness training, often phishing simulations
  • A tested incident response plan
  • Call-backs for supplier bank changes

Why the answers matter more than they used to

The questionnaire is not a formality: answers shape whether and on what terms you are covered, and policy wording may refer back to them. Tick "MFA on all remote access", suffer a breach through a VPN account without it, and claim time gets difficult.

As the federal Get Cyber Safe program puts it, a policy is one part of a risk strategy, not a replacement for cyber resilience (Get Cyber Safe).

Not insurance advice. We are not insurance advisers and this is not legal or insurance advice: how a policy responds depends on wording your broker and counsel should explain. Our role: making sure what you tell your insurer is true, and that you can show it.

The controls, and what "yes" should really mean

ControlWhat "yes" should mean
MFAEvery user, not most: shared mailboxes, service and break-glass accounts, third-party support access. The Cyber Centre recommends phishing-resistant options such as FIDO keys, and number matching against MFA fatigue (MFA rollout guide).
EDR and monitoringInstalled and answered: insurers increasingly ask who responds. Servers and Macs are often missed; know who acts at night (managed EDR vs DIY).
BackupsOffline or immutable copies, separate credentials, encryption, restore tests. A "success" report is not evidence you can recover.
PatchingHow fast critical updates land; unsupported systems retired, or isolated and documented.
Privileged accessSeparate admin accounts, few holders, MFA on all.
Email and paymentsFiltering, SPF, DKIM, DMARC; bank detail changes confirmed by phone on a number you already hold.
Training and planningLast training cycle and incident response exercise, with dates and attendance.
What Canadian government guidance adds
  • Get Cyber Safe: insurers assess risk by asking about security audits, safeguards for systems access and how data is handled; organizations with strong risk management may be offered coverage at a lower premium.
  • Canadian Centre for Cyber Security: its baseline controls for small and medium organizations line up closely with these questions, and it suggests considering insurance that covers incident response and recovery.

Rather talk it through? If your renewal questionnaire is on someone's desk right now, we can verify the answers and gather the evidence with you. Talk to a Promatics specialist

Build an evidence pack before renewal

Brokers and underwriters ask better questions every year; a short evidence pack saves time and cuts the risk of a wrong answer.

Cyber insurance evidence pack

  • MFA enrolment report for all users and admins, exceptions explained
  • Devices and servers with EDR; who monitors alerts after hours
  • Backup design summary; date and result of last full restore test
  • Patch compliance report; unsupported systems and their compensating controls
  • Privileged accounts and who holds them
  • SPF, DKIM and DMARC status for each domain
  • Payment change verification procedure
  • Training records and phishing simulation summary
  • Incident response plan with the date of the last exercise
  • Contacts: IT provider, counsel and the insurer's breach line

Keep it current: it also answers large clients' security questionnaires.

What usually goes wrong

Answering from memory

Someone remembers turning MFA on, not that a group of users was excluded.

Licences, not controls

You own an EDR licence, but the agent never reached the servers.

Last-minute changes

MFA forced on the day before renewal: lockouts, then exceptions nobody removes.

Forgotten suppliers

Your IT provider's or software vendor's remote access counts too.

When to bring in help

A small environment with a clear-headed IT person can gather most of this from existing admin consoles. Bring in a professional when answers are uncertain or inconsistent, the insurer has declined, added exclusions or asked for controls you lack, gaps must close in weeks, or you want someone accountable for the evidence.

A chatbot can explain a questionnaire; it cannot check your tenant, confirm server coverage or stand behind the answer. A Promatics security assessment reviews how you are really set up, ranks the gaps and gives you evidence and a remediation plan in plain language.

Limitations

Insurer requirements vary and change; this describes commonly asked controls in general terms, not insurance or legal advice. We do not predict whether any insurer will offer, renew or pay under a policy: discuss coverage and wording with your broker.

Sources and further reading

Product capabilities and guidance change. These are the primary sources this article relies on, checked on the review date above.

  1. Does your small business need cyber insurance?, Get Cyber Safe, Government of Canada
  2. Baseline cyber security controls for small and medium organizations, Canadian Centre for Cyber Security
  3. Secure your accounts and devices with multi-factor authentication (ITSAP.30.030), Canadian Centre for Cyber Security

This article is general information, not legal, accounting or security advice for your specific situation. Examples are hypothetical unless stated otherwise.

Talk to Promatics

Answer your insurer's questionnaire with evidence, not guesses

Renewal questionnaires arrive at busy times with specific questions. We check what is in place, close quick gaps and give you evidence to stand behind.

  • We verify each control rather than taking settings on trust
  • Plain-language evidence pack for your broker and leadership
  • A remediation plan for gaps before the renewal date