The short answer
Before you sign, a good provider shows it understands the problem, has a delivery method with acceptance tests and a clear "done", gives an honest estimate, handles data and access responsibly (subcontractors included) and plans documentation, handover and exit. Price matters, but a low estimate with vague scope is usually the most expensive by the end.
Criteria that matter
Judge every provider on eight criteria; the questions below test each one.
- Discovery first
- Checkable experience
- The actual people
- A visible method
- An honest estimate
- Security and data
- Handover and ownership
- Independence
What to look for under each criterion
| Criterion | What to look for |
|---|---|
| Discovery first | Processes, data, systems, constraints, who decides; not a price after one call. Paid discovery is normal for larger projects. |
| Checkable experience | Similar work; references you can call about what went wrong and how it was handled |
| The actual people | Who configures, builds, migrates and trains; employees or subcontractors; meet the lead first |
| A visible method | Stages, deliverables, testing, your approvals; progress in working software, not only reports |
| An honest estimate | Assumptions, exclusions (licences, hardware, third-party fees, out-of-scope work), your team's part, cost drivers, change handling |
| Security and data | Credential storage, who gets access, whether data leaves Canada, copies at the end |
| Handover and ownership | Who owns configuration, code, integrations and documentation; can someone else pick up later |
| Independence | Resale or vendor fees disclosed, so you can weigh recommendations |
The Canadian Centre for Cyber Security's guidance on assessing cyber supply chain risk suggests looking at a supplier's ownership and location, cyber maturity and your own ability to manage the risk it introduces.
Canadian obligations to keep in mind
- Privacy. Under PIPEDA your organization stays accountable for personal information it transfers to a service provider. The Office of the Privacy Commissioner's cross-border guidance says to use contractual or other means to provide comparable protection, and to tell people plainly if their information may be processed in another country. Provincial laws such as Quebec's Law 25 may add requirements.
- Federally regulated financial institutions must also follow OSFI's Third-Party Risk Management Guideline (B-10): due diligence proportionate to risk, written contracts and subcontracting.
- Accessibility and language. For public-facing websites or customer documents, confirm how accessibility and French-language needs are handled.
This is general information, not legal advice.
Questions to ask any provider
Understanding and approach
- What do you understand our problem to be, in your own words?
- What must you learn before committing to a fixed scope?
- What would make you advise against going ahead, or another product?
Team and experience
- Who exactly will work on our project, and in which roles?
- Any subcontractors? Where are they based, and will they access our data?
- Can we call two similar clients, including one where things went wrong?
Delivery and quality
- What are the stages, and what do we approve after each?
- How will we test the work, and who writes the acceptance tests?
- How do you handle changes to scope, and how are they priced?
Estimate and commercial terms
- What does the estimate assume, and what does it exclude?
- Which costs are fixed, and which depend on time spent?
- Do you get commissions or referral fees from vendors you recommend?
Security and data
- How do you store and share credentials for our systems?
- Where is our data stored and processed, and does any leave Canada?
- What happens to our data, access and copies when the project ends?
Handover, support and exit
- What documentation will we receive, and in what format?
- Who owns custom code, configuration and integrations?
- What support follows go-live, and how are response targets agreed?
- If we switch providers, how will you help with the transition?
Questions a good provider will ask you
Its questions tell you a lot; expect:
- Who makes decisions
- What success looks like
- Which systems and data are involved
- What your team can commit
- What is truly fixed: budget, deadline, regulation
- What has been tried before
If it asks none of this, be cautious.
Warning signs
- A firm price before anyone sees your data or processes
- No written exclusions, or "everything included"
- Unnamed team, no references
- Promised savings, or no downtime at all
- No testing, training or handover
- Terms that trap your data, code or documentation
Comparing providers fairly
Send every shortlisted provider the same brief (problem, systems, constraints) and any checklist you completed, such as the ERP evaluation checklist or build, buy or integrate worksheet. Score responses against the criteria, with weights agreed beforehand. For ongoing IT support, see how to choose a managed service provider in Canada.
Limitations
No questions remove all risk: a provider can answer well and deliver poorly, so stage approvals, acceptance tests and the ability to change course matter more than any answer.
Next step
Ask us every question on this list; our approach is on how we work. For an independent view before choosing a provider or platform, see IT consulting and advisory.
Sources and further reading
Product capabilities and guidance change. These are the primary sources this article relies on, checked on the review date above.
- Cyber supply chain: An approach to assessing risk (ITSAP.10.070), Canadian Centre for Cyber Security
- Guidelines for processing personal data across borders, Office of the Privacy Commissioner of Canada
- Third-Party Risk Management Guideline (B-10), Office of the Superintendent of Financial Institutions
- PIPEDA requirements in brief, Office of the Privacy Commissioner of Canada
This article is general information, not legal, accounting or security advice for your specific situation. Examples are hypothetical unless stated otherwise.